Want to know the best Thomas Mitchell movies? How about the worst Thomas Mitchell movies? Curious about Thomas Mitchell box office grosses or which Thomas Mitchell movie picked up the most Oscar® nominations? Need to know which Thomas Mitchell movie got the best reviews from critics and audiences? Well you have come to the right place.
Thomas Mitchell (1892-1962) was an Oscar® winning American actor. His IMDb page shows 111 acting credits from 1923-1961. In the table below, Ultimate Movie Rankings ranks 57 of his movies in 6 different sortable columns. Television roles, his one silent and his one uncredited role were not included in the rankings.
Drivel Part of the Page: In our imaginary UMR Classic Movie Character Actors Hall of Fame, Thomas Mitchell would be a First Ballot Hall of Famer. Joining the likes of Lionel Barrymore, Peter Lorre, Donald Crisp, Vincent Price, Barry Fitzgerald, Walter Brennan and Sydney Greenstreet. Future inductees (no UMR pages yet) include Charles Bickford, Charles Coburn and Ward Bond.
Thomas Mitchell Movies Ranked In Chronological Order With Ultimate Movie Rankings Score (1 to 5 UMR Tickets) *Best combo of box office, reviews and awards.
Year
Movie (Year)
Rating
S
Year Movie (Year) Rating S
1939
Gone with the Wind (1939)
AA Best Picture Win
1952
High Noon (1952)
AA Best Picture Nom
1939
Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939)
AA Best Picture Nom
1946
It's a Wonderful Life (1946)
AA Best Picture Nom
1939
Stagecoach (1939)
AA Best Picture Nom
AA Best Supp Actor Win
1937
Lost Horizon (1937)
AA Best Picture Nom
1944
Wilson (1944)
AA Best Picture Nom
1939
The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1939)
1939
Only Angels Have Wings (1939)
1944
The Keys of the Kingdom (1944)
1942
The Black Swan (1942)
1943
Immortal Sargeant (1943)
1942
Tales of Manhattan (1942)
1946
The Dark Mirror (1946)
1943
Bataan (1943)
1942
This Above All (1942)
1937
The Hurricane (1937)
AA Best Supp Actor Nom
1936
Theodora Goes Wild (1936)
1943
The Outlaw (1943)
1943
Flesh and Fantasy (1943)
1937
Make Way For Tomorrow (1937)
1947
High Barbaree (1947)
1944
The Fighting Sullivans (1944)
1944
Buffalo Bill (1944)
1942
Song of the Islands (1942)
1945
Adventure (1945)
1940
The Long Voyage Home (1940)
AA Best Picture Nom
1947
The Romance of Rosy Ridge (1947)
1948
Silver River (1948)
1938
Trade Winds (1938)
1946
Three Wise Fools (1946)
1936
Craig's Wife (1936)
1940
Our Town (1940)
AA Best Picture Nom
1961
Pocketful of Miracles (1961)
1954
Destry (1954)
1937
When You're in Love (1937)
1936
Adventure in Manhatten (1936)
1937
I Promise To Pay (1937)
1949
The Big Wheel (1949)
1940
Swiss Family Robinson (1940)
1940
Angels Over Broadway (1940)
1942
Joan of Paris (1942)
1945
Captain Eddie (1945)
1954
Secret of the Incas (1954)
1942
Moontide (1942)
1949
Alias Nick Beal (1949)
1956
While The City Sleeps (1956)
1937
Man of the People (1937)
1941
Flight From Destiny (1941)
1944
Dark Waters (1944)
1940
3 Cheers for the Irish (1940)
1941
Out of the Fog (1941)
1945
Within These Walls (1945)
1961
By Love Possessed (1961)
1951
Journey Into Light (1951)
1958
Handle With Care (1958)
1938
Love Honor and Behave (1938)
Thomas Mitchell Movies Can Be Ranked 6 Ways In This Table
The really cool thing about this table is that it is “user-sortable”. Rank the movies anyway you want.
- Sort Thomas Mitchell movies by movie titles and trailers
- Sort Thomas Mitchell movies by co-stars of his movies.
- Sort Thomas Mitchell movies by adjusted domestic box office grosses using current movie ticket cost (in millions)
- Sort Thomas Mitchell movies by yearly domestic box office rank
- Sort Thomas Mitchell movies how they were received by critics and audiences. 60% rating or higher should indicate a good movie.
- Sort by how many Oscar® nominations each Thomas Mitchell movie received and how many Oscar® wins each Thomas Mitchell movie won.
- Sort Thomas Mitchell movies by Ultimate Movie Rankings (UMR) Score. UMR Score puts box office, reviews and awards into a mathematical equation and gives each movie a score.
R
Movie (Year)
UMR Co-Star Links
Adj. B.O. Worldwide (mil)
Review
Oscar Nom / Win
UMR Score
R Movie (Year) UMR Co-Star Links Actual B.O. Domestic (mil) Adj. B.O. Domestic (mil) Adj. B.O. Worldwide (mil) B.O. Rank by Year Review Oscar Nom / Win UMR Score S
1
Gone with the Wind (1939)
AA Best Picture WinClark Gable &
Vivien Leigh56.60
2,179.1
3,842.80
1
92
13 / 08
100.0
4
High Noon (1952)
AA Best Picture NomGary Cooper &
Grace Kelly9.40
185.1
185.10
12
92
07 / 04
99.6
2
Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939)
AA Best Picture NomJames Stewart &
Claude Rains9.60
369.6
369.60
3
89
11 / 01
99.6
3
It's a Wonderful Life (1946)
AA Best Picture NomJames Stewart &
Donna Reed8.90
299.4
299.40
27
94
05 / 00
99.6
6
Stagecoach (1939)
AA Best Picture Nom
AA Best Supp Actor WinJohn Wayne &
Directed by John Ford5.00
191.3
298.80
30
83
07 / 02
99.2
5
Lost Horizon (1937)
AA Best Picture NomRonald Colman &
Directed by Frank Capra5.30
219.6
219.60
15
78
07 / 02
99.0
7
Wilson (1944)
AA Best Picture NomAlexander Knox &
Vincent Price6.50
217.3
217.30
37
69
10 / 05
98.8
8
The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1939)
Charles Laughton &
Maureen O'Hara7.50
287.7
593.20
11
83
02 / 00
98.3
9
Only Angels Have Wings (1939)
Cary Grant &
Jean Arthur4.80
184.8
184.80
33
85
02 / 00
97.7
9
The Keys of the Kingdom (1944)
Gregory Peck &
Vincent Price7.70
260.8
260.80
25
73
04 / 00
96.7
10
The Black Swan (1942)
Tyrone Power &
Maureen O'Hara8.60
318.6
318.60
12
71
03 / 01
96.2
11
Immortal Sargeant (1943)
Henry Fonda &
Maureen O'Hara7.10
256.7
256.70
32
73
00 / 00
95.9
12
Tales of Manhattan (1942)
Henry Fonda &
Ginger Rogers7.10
265.5
265.50
18
73
00 / 00
95.8
14
The Dark Mirror (1946)
Olivia de Havilland
7.40
228.9
228.90
48
68
01 / 00
94.9
16
Bataan (1943)
Robert Taylor
5.90
210.4
320.00
44
67
00 / 00
94.5
15
This Above All (1942)
Tyrone Power &
Joan Fontaine6.30
233.7
233.70
22
61
04 / 01
93.9
19
The Hurricane (1937)
AA Best Supp Actor NomDorothy Lamour &
Directed by John Ford4.40
182.4
182.40
30
69
01 / 00
93.7
20
Theodora Goes Wild (1936)
Irene Dunne &
Melvyn Douglas3.80
161.8
161.80
35
73
02 / 00
93.1
17
The Outlaw (1943)
Jane Russell &
Directed by Howard Hawks14.50
521.0
521.00
3
59
00 / 00
92.0
21
Flesh and Fantasy (1943)
Barbara Stanwyck &
Edward G. Robinson5.10
184.8
184.80
55
63
00 / 00
91.7
21
Make Way For Tomorrow (1937)
Victor Moore &
Directed by Leo McCarey2.90
118.6
118.60
81
83
00 / 00
91.4
22
High Barbaree (1947)
Van Johnson &
June Allyson6.00
175.7
242.80
50
63
00 / 00
90.8
22
The Fighting Sullivans (1944)
Anne Baxter
3.20
108.7
108.70
99
82
01 / 00
90.4
25
Buffalo Bill (1944)
Joel McCrea &
Maureen O'Hara6.50
217.3
217.30
38
53
00 / 00
90.1
25
Song of the Islands (1942)
Betty Grable &
Victor Mature4.00
148.7
148.70
66
66
00 / 00
88.8
26
Adventure (1945)
Clark Gable &
Greer Garson11.80
374.3
537.10
11
49
00 / 00
88.6
26
The Long Voyage Home (1940)
AA Best Picture NomJohn Wayne &
Walter Wanger1.90
72.2
117.20
106
78
06 / 00
88.5
29
The Romance of Rosy Ridge (1947)
Van Johnson &
Janet Leigh4.90
143.3
192.50
70
65
00 / 00
88.0
30
Silver River (1948)
Errol Flynn &
Ann Sheridan5.70
154.2
247.10
55
60
00 / 00
87.5
31
Trade Winds (1938)
Fredric March &
Joan Bennett3.90
154.9
216.20
42
59
00 / 00
87.3
33
Three Wise Fools (1946)
Lionel Barrymore &
Cyd Charisse4.40
135.9
172.00
74
64
00 / 00
86.7
34
Craig's Wife (1936)
Rosalind Russell
2.80
119.7
119.70
70
68
00 / 00
86.4
33
Our Town (1940)
AA Best Picture NomMartha Scott &
William Holden1.80
68.4
68.40
117
77
00 / 00
85.7
32
Pocketful of Miracles (1961)
Bette Davis &
Glenn Ford7.00
101.9
101.90
33
67
03 / 00
84.6
35
Destry (1954)
Audie Murphy
4.30
100.4
100.40
72
64
00 / 00
81.3
36
When You're in Love (1937)
Cary Grant &
Grace Moore2.50
103.7
103.70
96
62
00 / 00
81.0
38
Adventure in Manhatten (1936)
Joel McCrea &
Jean Arthur3.10
133.0
133.00
54
52
00 / 00
80.3
37
I Promise To Pay (1937)
Chester Morris
2.30
95.3
95.30
102
63
00 / 00
79.7
39
The Big Wheel (1949)
Mickey Rooney &
Racing Movies4.20
104.5
104.50
83
59
00 / 00
79.3
40
Swiss Family Robinson (1940)
Freddie Bartholomew
1.70
64.6
97.90
125
66
01 / 00
75.5
41
Angels Over Broadway (1940)
Rita Hayworth &
Douglas Fairbanks Jr.2.00
78.6
78.60
96
62
01 / 00
75.5
42
Joan of Paris (1942)
Alan Ladd &
Paul Henreid1.40
53.4
122.10
153
69
01 / 00
74.5
44
Captain Eddie (1945)
Fred MacMurray &
Charles Bickford2.80
88.1
88.10
99
57
01 / 00
73.5
45
Secret of the Incas (1954)
Charlton Heston &
Robert Young4.00
93.7
93.70
83
55
00 / 00
73.0
43
Moontide (1942)
Ida Lupino &
Claude Rains1.20
45.9
45.90
161
69
01 / 00
72.0
46
Alias Nick Beal (1949)
Ray Milland
2.80
70.1
70.10
119
62
00 / 00
72.0
47
While The City Sleeps (1956)
Dana Andrews &
George Sanders2.60
50.4
50.40
125
66
00 / 00
69.2
49
Man of the People (1937)
Joseph Calleia
1.70
70.5
70.50
131
59
00 / 00
68.5
48
Flight From Destiny (1941)
Geraldine Fitzgerald
1.60
60.7
60.70
144
62
00 / 00
68.4
50
Dark Waters (1944)
Merle Oberon &
Franchot Tone2.10
69.5
69.50
115
57
00 / 00
66.1
51
3 Cheers for the Irish (1940)
Priscilla Lane
1.20
46.8
62.00
152
62
00 / 00
63.1
53
Out of the Fog (1941)
John Garfiled &
Ida Lupino1.90
71.4
71.40
124
51
00 / 00
57.8
52
Within These Walls (1945)
Mary Anderson
1.00
30.9
30.90
143
63
00 / 00
56.5
54
By Love Possessed (1961)
Lana Turner &
Directed by John Sturges5.30
77.0
77.00
43
48
00 / 00
55.9
55
Journey Into Light (1951)
Sterling Hayden
1.10
23.9
23.90
198
62
00 / 00
50.2
56
Handle With Care (1958)
Dean Jones
0.50
9.0
16.70
165
66
00 / 00
47.9
57
Love Honor and Behave (1938)
Priscilla Lane
1.20
48.7
63.90
156
47
00 / 00
33.7
Possibly Interesting Facts About Thomas Mitchell
1. Thomas John Mitchell was born in Elizabeth, New Jersey in 1892. The youngest of seven children born to Irish immigrants who settled in New Jersey, his father James Mitchell, worked in the newspaper industry and died when Thomas was a young boy; his mother’s name was Mary.
2. Thomas Mitchell’s nephew, James P. Mitchell, later served as Dwight Eisenhower’s Secretary of Labor.
3. Thomas Mitchell was a close friend of John Barrymore and became part of his Hollywood entourage of drinkers and raconteurs, which also included Charles MacArthur, W.C. Fields, Errol Flynn, Roland Young and Anthony Quinn.
4. When Thomas Mitchell won the Tony Award as Best Actor in a Musical for “Hazel Flagg”, a musical version of the film Nothing Sacred, he became the first performer to claim the Triple Crown of Acting awards: Tony, Emmy (as TV’s Best Actor of 1953) and Oscar®.
5. Thomas Mitchell won the Best Supporting Actor Oscar® for his role in 1939’s Stagecoach. He was nominated one other time……1937’s The Hurricane.
6. Thomas Mitchell was an avid collector of fine art, which included a Rembrandt panel acquired in 1940 from a Polish prince.
7. Thomas Mitchell appeared in nine Oscar® Best Picture nominees: Lost Horizon (1937), Stagecoach (1939), Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939), Gone with the Wind (1939), Our Town (1940), The Long Voyage Home (1940), Wilson (1944), It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) and High Noon (1952), with Gone with the Wind the only winner.
8. Thomas Mitchell was married three times and had two children.
9. 1939, what a year for Thomas Mitchell! In 1939, in addition to appearing in three movies nominated for an Academy Award® for Best Picture, he appeared in two other films that received nominations in other categories: The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1939) and Only Angels Have Wings (1939).
10. Check out Thomas Mitchell’s career compared to current and classic actors. Most 100 Million Dollar Movies of All-Time.
Watch Steve’s Thomas Mitchell YouTube Video
If you do a comment….please ignore the email address and website section.
Thomas Mitchell, is the # 79 most connected actor of the 1940’s.
Added Steve’s Thomas Mitchell YouTube Video to this page. Our thoughts found on his channel…found below.
Gotta love Thomas Mitchell. I just saw him in #37 The Secret of the Incas….with some guy named Chuck Helton. Good video. I have seen 18 of the ones listed…seems I should have seen more. Favorites include #14 Keys to the Kingdom, #12 The Black Swan, #8 Only Angels Have Wings and #2 It’s A Wonderful Life. Voted up and shared
Hi Bruce, I was raiding your index page for subjects and spotted Mitchell, busy actor. Your tally 18 of the 37 on the video, I’ve seen 16 and Flora out in front with 27.
Thanks as always for the comment, vote and share, much appreciated.
I have already mentioned in Part 2 Steve’s wonderful overall set of posters/stills for GWTW and here is my personal pick of the remaining classy STILLS in the video.
1/Adventure
2/Silver River
3/Destry. I had forgotten Thomas was in that one
4/Buffalo Bill
5.Angels over Broadway
6/Immortal Sgt
7/Bataan – which seems like a studio pose with the Cowboy of the Century
8/The Hurricane
9/Tales of Manchester
10/Keys of the Kingdom – Greg’s 2nd movie and first TOP-BILLED starring role
11/two for The Black Swan – normally suave George does not suit that scraggly beard!
12/Long Voyage Home – call me biased but I always welcome a Duke photo
13/Only Angels have Wings
14/The Hunchback
15/Lost Horizon – splendid offering
16/Mr Smith Goes to Washington
17/the Stagecoach cast assembly publicity photo– Ford was fond of photographing those types of gatherings!
18/It’s a Wonderful Life
19/Alias Nick Beale. Although Ray Milland had the title role and Mitchell was billed 3rd [and not with even equal lettering to Milland’s name] reviewers have commented that Mitchell unusually actually had the main role. I may have seen it but can’t remember.
NOTE: A relatively large numbers of STILLS did not include Thomas – eg Destry. They were nevertheless excellent and I have listed some of them above as being among my own faves; but I couldn’t help wondering if Steve had difficulty in locating sufficient suitable stills involving Thomas. A standout offering was the beautiful coloured one of him with Vivien in GWTW – top marks for that one; and I liked WH’s gorgeous miniature solo above of Thomas in that movie
Great UMR Page
Firstly I thought the run of posters/stills from GWTW was sensational. Gable’s agent on hearing Crawford was after the part of Scarlett “I hope my boy’s not going to have top-billing problems!” Studio executive reply “Clark will have NO billing problems.” Other great POSTERS in Steve’s Mitchell video
1/Secret of the Incas – a forgotten Chuck heyday entertainer.
2/first one for The Outlaw
3/Dark Waters
4/Pocketful of Miracles-Charley Bill on the way out in terms of stardom. Clashes between him and Bette on set as he wanted to demote Davis by installing his mistress in Bette’s prestige dressing room and demanding she move down one. She refused.
5/two for Destry – very original
6/two for Only Angels have Wings
7/first one for Swiss Family Robinson
8/This Above All – sounds like something WH would say about one of Joel’s critiques
9/Out of The Fog
10/The Hurricane – Jon Hall appeared recently in a rerun of an old Perry Mason episode.
11/Theodora Goes Wild – awful stuff for my money!
12/first one for The Black Swan. “One day you will call me Jamie Boy!” – swashbuckler Power to spitfire O’Hara
13/Long Voyage Home – a forgotten routine Duke item of yesteryear
14/Make Way for Tomorrow
15.Angles over Broadway
16/2 absolute stunners for Hunchback – how do you keep coming up with such great stuff Steve?
17/entire set for Lost Horizon
18/two very original ones for High Noon
19/foreign language one for Stagecoach.
20/Second one for It’s a Wonderful Life
21/While the City Sleeps – one of my all time fave movies; and the two posters which I had never before seen [except maybe once on Lensman] are actually the best posters that I have come across to date for that movie. Sheer joy to view as posters